Tuesday, April 24, 2012
Holy crap how wrong was I?
If you recall my election prediction fun, it is quite obvious that I am terrible at predicting outcomes of elections. I was WAY off on my seat predictions, as was pretty much everyone else. And of the 10 bonus questions asked I only got 5 right. Fail.
Sunday, April 22, 2012
Election Prediction Fun #2
Now this is more to show the uselessness of public opinion polls and seat projections. I will post the final polling results and seat projections from numerous sources, all of which were published here except the Forum poll which was published here.
First off, the popular vote percentages.
Now, for the even more shaky art of seat projections. These come from Forum, Threehundredeight, and Daveberta average pool responses.
Using the Hill & Knowlton Election Seat predictor tool, I've arrived at my own seat projections using the various poll firms voting intention data both on a whole Alberta basis and a regional basis. Both of these methods yield a slim Wildrose majority, varying in composition based on full province data or regional data.
Full province data yields the following:
Wildrose 47
PC 32
NDP 8
Other 0
Regional Data yields the following:
Wildrose 46
PC 29
NDP 10
Lib 2
However, of course, all of this information is based on decided voters. The undecided will determine the fate of our province. The H&K election predictor allows you to see the impact of votes swinging from one camp to another. Let's evaluate a few scenarios based on province-wide data.
1. Half of Liberal leaning voters vote PC to stop a Wildrose government from forming
Minority Wildrose government with 43 seats, PC 37, NDP 7
2. Half of all NDP leaning voters vote PC to stop a Wildrose government from forming
Wildrose majority with 44 seats, PC 41, NDP 2
3. Half of Liberal and half of NDP voters vote PC
PC majority at 45, Wildrose 40, NDP 2
4. 100% of Liberal voters toss their support behind the NDP
Still results in a Wildrose majority
5. NDPers listen to Raj Sherman and toss all their support behind him
Still a Wildrose majority
So you can see from this that there are only two scenarios where Wildrose does NOT form a majority government. Either Liberal voters swing in large numbers to the PCs, or both Liberal and NDP voters swing to the PCs.
So, given all this, and that a good 20% of those planning to vote are currently undecided, and of those, more are leaning toward the PCs, I am predicting a close Wildrose MINORITY government. After looking at all this I still stand beside my original predictions for the Daveberta election prediction pool posted here.
I will post how well all of these aligned with the actual results after the election as well as the results of my alternative election.
I know, you can't contain your excitement. It's okay. I totally understand.
First off, the popular vote percentages.
| Party | Leger | Think HQ | Campaign | Abacus | Forum | Average |
| Wildrose | 42 | 41 | 41 | 41 | 41 | 41.2 |
| PC | 36 | 33 | 34 | 31 | 32 | 33.2 |
| NDP | 10 | 11 | 11 | 13 | 13 | 11.6 |
| Lib | 9 | 11 | 11 | 12 | 10 | 10.6 |
| Other | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3.4 |
Now, for the even more shaky art of seat projections. These come from Forum, Threehundredeight, and Daveberta average pool responses.
| Party | Forum | THE | Daveberta | Average | |
| Wildrose | 62 | 45 | 42 | 49 | |
| PC | 19 | 37 | 37 | 32 | |
| NDP | 4 | 4 | 4 | 5 | |
| Lib | 2 | 1 | 3 | 1 | |
| Other | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
Using the Hill & Knowlton Election Seat predictor tool, I've arrived at my own seat projections using the various poll firms voting intention data both on a whole Alberta basis and a regional basis. Both of these methods yield a slim Wildrose majority, varying in composition based on full province data or regional data.
Full province data yields the following:
Wildrose 47
PC 32
NDP 8
Other 0
Regional Data yields the following:
Wildrose 46
PC 29
NDP 10
Lib 2
However, of course, all of this information is based on decided voters. The undecided will determine the fate of our province. The H&K election predictor allows you to see the impact of votes swinging from one camp to another. Let's evaluate a few scenarios based on province-wide data.
1. Half of Liberal leaning voters vote PC to stop a Wildrose government from forming
Minority Wildrose government with 43 seats, PC 37, NDP 7
2. Half of all NDP leaning voters vote PC to stop a Wildrose government from forming
Wildrose majority with 44 seats, PC 41, NDP 2
3. Half of Liberal and half of NDP voters vote PC
PC majority at 45, Wildrose 40, NDP 2
4. 100% of Liberal voters toss their support behind the NDP
Still results in a Wildrose majority
5. NDPers listen to Raj Sherman and toss all their support behind him
Still a Wildrose majority
So you can see from this that there are only two scenarios where Wildrose does NOT form a majority government. Either Liberal voters swing in large numbers to the PCs, or both Liberal and NDP voters swing to the PCs.
So, given all this, and that a good 20% of those planning to vote are currently undecided, and of those, more are leaning toward the PCs, I am predicting a close Wildrose MINORITY government. After looking at all this I still stand beside my original predictions for the Daveberta election prediction pool posted here.
I will post how well all of these aligned with the actual results after the election as well as the results of my alternative election.
I know, you can't contain your excitement. It's okay. I totally understand.
Election Prediction Fun #1
I know. It's an oxymoron. But some of us do consider elections to be fun. Hence, my reason for posting this. I have done various election predictions and will post the results below. After the election, I will see how terrible I did.
The Daveberta Election Pool
I entered an election pool over at Daveberta.ca. Not really for the prizes, which are nerdy politics books, but just for shits and giggles.
Here are my responses to his questions.
Number of MLAs elected by each party (total: 87 MLAs)
The Daveberta Election Pool
I entered an election pool over at Daveberta.ca. Not really for the prizes, which are nerdy politics books, but just for shits and giggles.
Here are my responses to his questions.
Number of MLAs elected by each party (total: 87 MLAs)
Alberta Party: 0
Liberal: 1
NDP: 5
PC: 40
Wildrose: 41
Other: 0
Liberal: 1
NDP: 5
PC: 40
Wildrose: 41
Other: 0
1. The constituency where the PC candidate will earn their highest percentage of the popular vote: Griffiths: Battle River-Wainwright
2. Will PC MLA Ted Morton be re-elected in Chestermere-Rockyview? No
3. Will Premier Alison Redford be re-elected in Calgary-Elbow? Yes
4. Will Liberal Party leader Raj Sherman be re-elected in Edmonton-Meadowlark? Yes
5. What will the highest vote percentage for the Alberta Party be in a riding? Lacombe-Ponoka
6. Will either Allan Hunsperger (“gays burn in hell”) or Ron Leech (“being white is an advantage”) win their seat? No
7. Who will be elected in Edmonton-Glenora? Ray Martin-NDP
8. Which party leaders will announce plans to resign within 48 hours of the vote? Redford
9. How many of the 3 senate positions will the Wildrose Party win? 0
10. Who will get more votes – Liberals or NDP? NDP
Wednesday, April 18, 2012
My alternative election wish
As I have done for pretty much every election in my living memory, I am going to analyze the results of this provincial election in a different light. I envy the people of New Zealand, because as far as I am concerned they have one of the fairest, simplest, and most representative voting systems in the developed world.
Here is how it works.
The national parliament is divided into thirds. Two-thirds of the seats are constituency seats. One-third are called list seats. When a voter gets to the ballot box, the ballot would look something like this, using my riding as an example.
1. Choose your preferred candidate.
Forsyth, Alan-Wildrose
Laurin, Wanda-NDP
Oberle, Frank-PC
Tardif, Remi-Liberal
2. Choose your preferred party
Liberal
NDP
PC
Wildrose
You get two choices on each ballot. So, for example, in my riding, if I really liked, say, Mr. Oberle, the incumbent, because he is a hard-working, honest MLA, I could vote for him but still support the, say, NDP party. Just a hypothetical here.
Then, this is how the results work. They add up the votes for all the parties to arrive at a popular vote percentage. Using a mathematical method called the Saint-Lague formula, they allocate the number of seats each party is allotted as a percentage of the total seats in the Parliament. The formula just allows for equal allotments of seats and avoids rounding errors in favor of one party over another.
Now, in each constituent riding, whoever gets the most votes wins. So, let's say the PCs got 30 members elected in their constituencies but their popular vote allotted them 4o seats. They would now get 10 extra members elected into Parliament in the list seats. These would be taken from a prepublished and predetermined "list" posted by each party before the election.
Here is how I see this working in Alberta and how I have set it up to analyze the results after election day and come up with an "alternative" Legislature in Alberta.
I've taken each of the 87 ridings in Alberta and come up with an alternative alignment. It is rough and if it was ever done more strict criteria would be involved. I basically just took the 3 closest by geography. So let's say 3 Northwest Alberta ridings as an example. They would be lumped together, then split in 2. Those 2 ridings would be 2 constituent seats. The whole of the 2 ridings would be a list seat. So the people in each riding would have an MLA for themselves, and then 1 list MLA would oversee the larger area represented by the 2 ridings. The 2 constituent MLAs would be voted in as they are now. The list MLA could come from a predetermined list or they could look at the candidates for each party with the highest levels of popular support province-wide and give out the list seats remaining for each party in descending order of support gained.
So this is what I shall do. I will look at the results in each riding. Whichever 2 candidates get the highest percentage of popular vote in their ridings will be my "constituent" MLAs in those 2 ridings out of the 3 I lump together. The remaining candidates will go onto the list.
I'm interested to see how this method will realign the seat allotment in Alberta and also the MLA makeup in the Legislature. It is only a completely nerdy academic exercise on my part, but I hope to see a proportional representation system similar to that used in New Zealand adopted in Alberta some day, and, more hopefully, across Canada.
Wednesday, April 4, 2012
Alberta Heritage Fund in disrepair
Below is an e-mail I sent to Danielle Smith, leader of the surging Alberta Wildrose Party. As they look poised to form Alberta's next government, their policies and announcements need to be analyzed carefully. As you'll see below, at least one of these policies, although very popular among some voters, is shortsighted and not what I expect of my political leaders.
I initially read with great interest and excitement your proposal to finally bring the Alberta Heritage Fund to a respectable level. I was confused and disappointed when I later read your proposal to pay a $300 "energy dividend" to every Albertan.
The mindset that initially drove Ralph Klein to give us all "prosperity cheques" is no different than the one behind your announcement to pay us each $300. It is, no doubt, the same mindset that has flourished under 40 years of Conservative rule in this province and led to the pathetic current market value of the Alberta Heritage Fund. The fact that you announced it as a key policy plank leads me to believe that Wildrose rule may be no different, and that disappoints me. I found your policy platform very well thought out and not as "right wing" as many claim your party to be. But to implement this $300 policy would be evidence that your party knows nothing of responsible governance or fiscal management and thus, are no different than the Conservatives.
What you, Ms. Redford, Mr. Mason, and Dr. Sherman all need to hear is that the people of Alberta elect our government to make difficult and complex decisions on our behalf for the betterment of our province and its future. If you want to give us each $300 per year, lower our personal income taxes. Taking the money from us and then giving it back is not only a huge administrative expense but brings into question our leaders' creativity and passion for future generations. It takes a real leader to think beyond their lifetime and invest for the future. That is exactly what the leaders of Norway have been doing since 1990. And by every measure imaginable, the Alberta Heritage Fund is an absolute embarrassment compared to the Norwegian sovereign wealth fund.
If you consider Alberta as a unique political entity, our Heritage Fund lags Norway's as a percentage of government revenue, government expenditure, GDP, annual petroleum revenue, and dollars per capita. It is even more embarrassing to learn that the Heritage Fund's inception was in 1976 while Norway only started in 1990. Even with that temporal handicap the latter has a full $500 billion more in value. Even considering equal starting points, an aggregate average of all the measures for Norway's fund would suggest that ours should contain $211 billion by now had our leaders been as responsible and forward-thinking as those in Norway.
What if the Conservatives of 1976 invested $300 in 1976 dollars (roughly $75) for each Albertan (1.8 million at the time) in the Heritage Fund, and continued to do so until now? At a very modest growth of 3% per year and converting it into 2012 dollars, it would put the value at $33.8 billion, double its existing value. Instead, it looks like we've invested only $250 million in 2012 dollars for 35 years, only 0.71% of total government revenue. Clearly we can AND must do better.
Think, Mrs. Smith, of the legacy you could leave if you were to abandon your reckless proposal and focus on bringing the Heritage Fund to its fair value? Your original proposal of $200 billion is right on the money. This would be a Heritage Fund to be proud of. This would show fearless and intellectual leadership. The hard working people of Alberta deserve nothing less.
Friday, March 23, 2012
Real Gourmet? Really?
I saw a commercial last night for Michelina's new Real Gourmet line. As it says on the commercial, and on the website, you get just real food, never any preservatives.
Get real food with Real Gourmet™, new from Michelina’s®. For years, you’ve known us best for our iconic green box that you’ve been enjoying since 1992. But now you’ll know us for our unique parchment pouch that steam cooks each wholesome meal to perfection. With Michelina's® Real Gourmet™ you get real cuts of seasoned meat, a full serving of vegetables, and never any preservatives. This calls for the good china, every day.
Aside from the ridiculousness of calling something you pull out a box and nuke in the microwave "real food", one could argue, if it were indeed real food, that it is no different than making multiple servings of homemade food and freezing the leftovers. So do the ingredients actually contain JUST real food? Here they are for the Beef Bourguignon.
ROASTED RED POTATOES (WITH DEXTROSE, SODIUM PHOSPHATE), SEASONED COOKED BEEF (BEEF, WATER, MODIFIED CORN STARCH, SALT, ONION POWDER, GARLIC POWDER), WATER, ROASTED ZUCCHINI, MUSHROOMS, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, ROASTED YELLOW PEPPERS, CORN STARCH, TOMATO PASTE, RED PORT WINE REDUCTION, VEGETABLE OIL (SOYBEAN, OLIVE POMACE), CELERY, ONIONS, GARLIC (CONTAINS WATER, CITRIC ACID [ACIDULANT]), FLAVOUR (CONTAINS MILK, SALT), BEEF STOCK (CONCENTRATED BEEF STOCK, YEAST EXTRACT, SALT, CORN OIL), SUGAR, FLAVOUR (POTASSIUM CHLORIDE, MALTODEXTRIN, DISODIUM INOSINATE, DISODIUM GUANYLATE, MODIFIED CORN STARCH, CORN SYRUP SOLIDS, FLAVOUR), YEAST EXTRACT, TOASTED ONION POWDER, PARSLEY FLAKES, SPICE, MIREPOIX FLAVOUR (SUNFLOWER OIL, FLAVOUR), GRANULATED GARLIC. CONTAINS: MILK
I don't know about you, but if I were making beef bourguignon at home, which I have in fact done, I would leave out sodium phosphate, citric acid, yeast extract, potassium chloride, maltodextrin, disodium inosinate, and disodium guanylate.
Now I could understand if they were putting this out for fresh consumption. But why all the crap when it is going straight into and out of the freezer? You can freeze food without all this other garbage in it. Calling this "real food" is an insult to the intelligence of anyone who ever cooks at home from whole ingredients.
Thursday, March 1, 2012
Debunking Dr. Oz-Day 1
I am following a blog that summarizes the insane recommendations made on Dr. Oz. And I'm doing this because, no word of a lie, EVERY SINGLE DAY I get someone who comes to me asking me if I carry some random, obscure product that I've never heard of. And now that I've started following this blog, I come home and read it and understand why they were asking me. Because Dr. Oz recommended it. And this concerns me. If he was just some guy who spouted off garbage that no one listens too, fine. But my patients actually intend on ingesting supplements and making changes in their health habits based on his information. To me, that is scary.
So, starting now, every time I get a request for something and I then see that it was featured on the Dr. Oz show, I'm going to tear it to shreds and expose it for the blatant sensationalistic ratings-grab that it is.
Today's ridiculous recommendation? Parasites may be the cause of your fatigue.
Problem #1: The whole premise. First of all, contrary to the statements of Dr. Oz and his guest, parasitic infections are NOT widespread. It's such an absurd idea that I'm not even going to justify it by referencing the facts unless someone really insists. Second, the whole diagnosis of chronic fatigue syndrome is incredibly contentious. Medical science is not even decided on what CFS exactly is, what causes it, and what symptomatology it represents. Because of that, there is no reliable way of stating its prevalence within a given population. Furthermore, there is only a SINGLE human study looking at the link between a SINGLE parasite (Giardia lamblia) and CFS. The study was poorly designed as it relied on mail questionnaires and did not control for lifestyle factors that could have explained the increase in CFS. And, if you can't agree on the diagnosis or definition of the condition you're studying, how valid are the results?
Problem #2: No evidence for the recommended therapies.
1. Garlic: Will not keep parasites away. There are no good quality human trials assessing the effects of garlic on human parasites. Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database, the best evidence-based reference for natural products, states that there is insufficient data to conclude any significant antimicrobial effect of garlic, despite the guest's claim that it is a "natural anti-microbial". So is ethanol.
2. Wormwood tea: This is the obscure question we got today. "Do you have any wormwood tea?" No in vivo human studies of any significance conducted using wormwood tea against intestinal parasites. No evidence whatsoever.
3. Papaya seeds with honey. I'll assume the honey is a crucial component? I love looking this stuff up. I get all sorts of results for experiments done in rats, pigs, and chickens. Fantastic. Again, no surprises. Absolutely no studies of significance in humans for this product. And in case you like using products tested in goats and lambs, it doesn't even work in them.
Conclusion:
Crap, crap, and more crap. Pretend treatments for pretend causes of pretend "diseases". If you have chronic fatigue, I'm not saying it is not potentially due to a medically significant condition. However, you are one unlucky soul if it is caused by a gastrointestinal parasite. Given your luck, I wouldn't hedge your bets on the useless products recommended by Dr. Oz.
Dr. Oz is not on TV to make you healthier. He is on TV to make himself rich and to do the same for the companies that make the products that he recommends. And every time I think he can't get any more ridiculous and make his medical degree look like more of a joke, he surprises me. Watch him for entertainment or just plain interest, or because you like watching intellectual train wrecks unfold before your eyes. BUT DO NOT WATCH HIM FOR RELIABLE, HONEST, SAFE, OR SCIENTIFICALLY VALIDATED MEDICAL INFORMATION. In fact, you'd be much better served from a health perspective if you spent that 30 minutes exercising.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)